Missions › Product reviews › L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir

Retired missionProduct review

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir

Added Nov 22, 2016

This mission has ended. See what is open now.

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir

About this product

L’Oréal Paris introduces Voluminous Liner Noir eyeliner. Create mesmerizing feline looks with the ultra-fine tip for sleek, easy application and rich black formula. Unique packaging shape provides added control and precision. All day wear Smudge resistant Smooth and precise application Ophthalmologist tested.

About L'Oreal

L'Oreal

Comments

112 reviews. Each one is a verified review of this product by a ShopperArmy member.

★☆☆☆☆

Millie H**** · Alberta

Smudge and Smear

Seems I am more of a pencil liner gal. I was able to apply the liner because the tip is firm-ish, thank goodness. And it didn't look so bad at first. But the black from my upper lid ended up under my eye and once I got that cleaned up, well, the liner just didn't have any staying power and was quite a mess. Pass!

★★★★★

Bareera N**** · Ontario

i liked it

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir is really amazing thing. its colour and texture is really good. it has great effect on eyes and eyes look big after using it. i recommend this product to all

★★★★☆

Stephanie P**** · Quebec

Purrfect Liner

I love this because it makes a purfect cat eye look. The stick is well designed so that it makes the movement fluient.

★★★★★

Munawar K**** · Ontario

impressing quality

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir is one of the nice product in the market. My spouse felt great after using it. Eyes look more beautiful than before after its use.i recommend it.

★★★★☆

Philana B**** · Ontario

Great liquid liner

I liked this liquid liner, although I liked the triangle shape of the pen and the way it fits in my hand, the cap only goes on one way so takes some effort to put back on after using the product.

★★★★☆

Lori C**** · Quebec

Meeeoooowww

Sextremely caty eyes made easier than ever before with Voluminous Liner noir from L'Oréal. Says it all!

★★★★☆

Sheena M**** · Ontario

Eyeliner

I liked this product to make cat eyes. I would buy again and again and again.

★★★★☆

Estrella S**** · Ontario

Sharp line, but leaks into eye

What I liked about this eyeliner was that it was very easy to draw sharp lines, exactly where I wanted them on my eyes. The only issue I had was that when using it under the eye, the liner leaked into my eye. I guess I'm used to using dry eyeliners that don't do this. Next time, I'll be drawing the line further from my eye, as I don't like the liner going into my eye.

★★★★★

Melissa S**** · Ontario

Impressed!

I'm in love with the tip! I'm really bad at wings and this makes it easier! You can't beat the price either! I'm used to paying atleast $20 for eyeliner and this is just as good and even better as some of the higher end ones!

★★★★★

Anna A**** · Ontario

Love it!

This eyeliner was easy to use and loved the rich black colour. It was easy to apply a thin line and to control the thickness of the line with more pressure.

★★★★☆

Connie M**** · Saskatchewan

Good quality eyeliner-doesnt smudge

I found this product makes a fine dark line as advertised on packaging. However line was light/pale unless on exact angle. Is more expensive than many other eyeliners,but does work well once a person gets used to the angle/pressure required to apply it. Thankyou.

★★★★★

Cara M**** · Ontario

Precision and easy to use

This eyeliner is very easy to use and I was able to make a very fine line. The eyeliner didn't smudge at all and looks great!!

★★★★★

Fatima P**** · Ontario

amazing

it glides on so smoothly and it is so pigmented. I love that it is so dark and looks amazing. i would recommend this to anyone

★★★★★

Jessica H**** · Ontario

My New Fave!

I wear winged eyeliner almost every day and so I have tried a lot of different liners from a wide range of brands. I was SUPER IMPRESSED by this liner! From the design of the packaging to the performance, it exceeded my expectations. It was sooo easy to do a winged liner. The applicator tip was sharp and had just the right amount of stiffness. The line was very dark matte black and wore well! For the price, it is outstanding! I will have to see how long it lasts before the felt tip dries out, but loving it so far. I hope this is part of the permanent line!

★★★★★

Kimberley F**** · Ontario

Easy to create fine lines

Prior to using this product, I had been using a liquid liner with a more flexible brush (the type where you dip it in a pot of liner and apply). I was expecting this product to be similar, and was surprised when it arrived and I discovered it was more of a pen style but with a long applicator. I was pleasantly surprised by just how easy it was to create both thin and think lines with this product - The brush is stiff enough that it is easy to use just the very tip and create a very fine line, and just as easy to angle it a bit and create a thicker one. The liner goes on very smoothly and even though I'm a bit of a makeup dunce, I needed to do very little cleanup after application (I usually need to do a lot!) The staying power is good and it stayed in place all day (even though I rub my eyes a lot), but it comes off easily with soap and water. I would definitely purchase this liner again.

★★★★☆

Kelly H**** · Ontario

Gorgeous Thick Eyes

I bought the L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir not knowing what to expect... I will be honest, I can't draw a simple line around my eyes so I had my daughter apply this for me... OMG!!! The transformation of my Eyes was incredible, I almost didn't recognize my own eyes!! I love how this looks... it went on easy, it is thick & dark when finished... I totally recommend this!!!

★★★★☆

Darlene W**** · Alberta

It went on smooth and applied easily

I found that the eye liner went on smoothly. It was easy to apply. It left a good line. I found it to last quite long.

★★★☆☆

Jennifer H**** · British Columbia

I need some lessons

Once I figured out how to use it, the results were gorgeous, but it did take some practice. I don't use a lot of makeup, except when I'm going out. I'll need to keep practicing my cat eyes, the pen like shape and length get some getting used to, but it's like using a liquid liner with the precision of a pencil. I went out dancing and it definitely lasted all night, and made my eyes look beautiful. It came off pretty easily, but I wish I'd taken it off before I went to bed, as I woke up with raccoon eyes. Lovely volume, nice and dark.

★★★★☆

Lisa N**** · Quebec

Quick drying

This liquid liner is easy to use and dries quicker than a pencil line and you barely need to dab the brush on the area around the eye to make your line. It is a bit difficult to remove though but not as bad as if it were waterproof mascara

★★★★☆

Stephanie L**** · Alberta

Great product

I found the product easy to use ,the long handle made it easier, I was in a rush when I tired it but it worked out well. It went on smooth and didn't smug. The color was just what I was going for and it seem to last all day long. I'm hoping it does last a long time so I can use this eyeliner daily or with out it drying up fast. I had to check a few stores to find this product but happy I did. I would buy this product again.

★★★★☆

Amanda B**** · Manitoba

Excellent quality

Nice easy flowing liner. For a first time user it took a little getting used to. First line was a little shaky. It was better after the trial run. I like that you can make the line as thick or thin as you like. It was also long lasting and did not smudge. Overall a quality product.

★★★★★

Vikram N**** · Alberta

Love it and it is great!

My wife loves using this. She says it is great and never smudges. Gives a perfect look after using it.

★★★★★

Joseph C**** · Ontario

Fine and easy to use

Very easy to use and so smooth. I don't have to apply again. It's fine liner and not messy at all.

★★★★★

Anna P**** · British Columbia

easy to use liner

This liner is super easy to use and the result is really good - you get that super fine line. I really like it, it's great for fast morning make up.

★★☆☆☆

Melissa F**** · Alberta

Not so smooth

The Loreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir is for more experienced users I am thinking. I found it to be not as smooth as I was hoping. I figured the small delicate brush would just glide on my eyelid and I would have a flawless line. But it was more like a paintbrush were you have to keep adding color to make a smooth stroke. Would also have liked to see other colors offered. Black tends to get so boring. For the price I won't be buying again will just stick to a regular pencil color. Would recommend to someone very experienced in makeup and definitely not a teenager.

★★★★★

Animesh W**** · Ontario

Loved the product

My wife loved the product and found it very easy to use and apply. All in all completly satisfied. Thanks

★☆☆☆☆

Chrissy M**** · Ontario

Does not go on smooth

I had a hard time getting a smooth line with the liquid liner on myself. Had to go over it several times. Looked messy. Might be better if you are a make up artist and are applying it on someone else. Frustrating for me.

★★★★☆

Christine G**** · Ontario

Precise, but hard to handle

I'm a pencil eyeliner kind of girl, so I was excited to try something new. The L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir was very precise in creating a dark line. However, you have to have a steady hand! It will take some getting used to if you're not used to a liquid type liner.

★★★☆☆

Sue P**** · Ontario

Requires practice to obtain the perfect line

It took me a few tries before I was able to obtain the look I wanted. The liner tip is very thin and since I am not used to a liquid liner my hand was not steady and produced a wobbly line.

★★★★☆

Jenna M**** · British Columbia

So easy to use!

This is definitely the easiest liquid liner I've use. It went on so smoothly and was really forgiving!

★★★☆☆

Alina H**** · British Columbia

Good for easy everyday use but didn't wow picky me

I found this liner helped me create that perfect cat eye, the stiff felt tip is great at making winged lines! Great ergonomics, it's easy to hold and create a thin or thicker line. It applies matte and I love that! I find the formula easy to apply, however after a week of use it seems to be getting a bit dryer. The tip is starting to soften and change its rigor a bit after a week as well, pretty much all felt tip liners do this. I would recommend this to anyone, even beginners. It's easy enough to apply. I find it dissipates a bit with prolonged use but I have some great tips: use eyelid primer or apply black eyeshadow on top for a beautiful smoky line. I don't recommend it if you have really oily lids or don't use primer. I also wouldn't recommend using this liner on long work shifts or extreme situations, like gym or childbirth ( don't laugh, many pictures are taken in the hospital room!). This is not a heavy duty liner. Bottom line: This is good for everyday use, easy to apply.

★★★☆☆

Clair C**** · Alberta

Went on smoothly, but no staying power

The liner was easy to apply and went on smoothly. I found that by the end of the day it would start to smear and didn't look as good as when it was first put on.

★★★★★

Sarah C**** · British Columbia

Game changer

I enjoy wearing eyeliner and I'm fond of a cat eye style. I liked the packaging of the liner, and I find it easy to use.

★★★☆☆

Jessica C**** · Alberta

Not the most effective liner

I use eye liner everyday, and am currently going through the prices of trying multiple brands. I found this liner to excel in the intensity of pigment. In my opinion the ease of application is where this product fails, it doesn't glide on smoothly. The liner is hard to apply evenly due to this, it seems to catch on your skin when applying. I do like the shape of the liner, but the cap should be changed to close in any way.

★★☆☆☆

Nicole B**** · Manitoba

Did not like this product

I found it hard to use as it was too fine to apply,was messy and had no sponge end to blend

★★★★☆

Sheila W**** · Saskatchewan

Great Quality Linear

Easy to use and easy on the budget. Was extremely easy to apply, loved the applicator.

★★★★☆

Jade L**** · Alberta

A good product

I did like this product for the simple fact that I have never really used a liquid eyeliner. It is definitely something you would have to use over and over to get it looking just right.

★★★★★

Elaine · British Columbia

Loreal Paris liner

I loved how easy the liner was to apply and how much precision it gave me

★★★☆☆

Kerri M**** · Alberta

Great cat eye but it ended up. Under my eye

My review title pretty much sums it up. I was able to create an amazingly easy cateye on both eyes but after a few hours I ended up looking less feline and more raccoon. I might still use this liner just because of the ease of use if I don't plan on being out all day or night. Just meh......

★★★★★

Lisa F**** · British Columbia

Love this liner!

This liner is great, I love the shape of the pen itself and I love how fine the tip is. I will be honest and tell you that I am horrible with felt liners but I felt like the shape of this one allowed me to have a more steady hand. The liner had good staying power and didn't irritate my eyes at all. Will purchase again!

★★★★★

Connie M**** · Manitoba

Long lasting wear

I found the Lóreal Paris Voluminous Liner easy to apply and stayed on all day. It went on a little sheer, but with layering became more opaque. Great for creating a thicker line and also for extending to a cat eye look.

★★★★☆

Fanny S**** · Ontario

Easy to use, but dries out quickly.

I don't usually use liquid liners because I find them messy, but this one is easy to use and does not smudge when applying it. It was easy drawing a fine line on my eyes, however I found the felt tip dried out quickly when I drew my second line on the other eye. I would suggest storing the liner tip down, just to make sure the product stays in the tip of the liner and it doesn't dry out as quickly. This product looks great and is super easy to use. I recommend it to anyone who uses makeup, even if you are not familiar with liquid liners, this one is great for beginners or experts!

★★★☆☆

Maria G**** · Ontario

Good enough for me

Finding the item was a nightmare as it doesn't stand out at you but aside from that the item itself is quite nice. The pigment is good. It hasn't bled out once it dried. I do like it. I find the package is nice as well with the gold but I don't understand the tip area. It's indented and I feel like if I accidentally hit my hand upon application it'll break off lol

★★★★☆

Alison G**** · Ontario

Glides on smooth

This liquid eyeliner has a precise applicator that help it go exactly where you want it and it goes on smoothly. Contrary to others I have tried, it also doesn't irritate the sensitive skin around your eye or burn if you get it too close.

★★★★☆

Candy L**** · Alberta

Clean and precise

The L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir allows for a clean and precise lines. It is very easy to use and makes putting make-up on easy.

★★★★☆

Sandra R**** · British Columbia

Great Liner

This liner is awesome. Went on smoothly with just one stroke. Nice deep black color.

★★★★★

Carolee P**** · Ontario

Fabulous liquid liner

This liquid eye liner is a wonderful product and comes with a brush that has a super-fine tip, making it very easy to get the look you want. The liner goes on smoothly and easily. The brush lets you put on wide strokes or thinner lines. You can easily get a nice wing on the side of your eye and then use the super tiny tip to adjust so it looks perfect. Once it dries, it has a nice matte look, and doesn't smudge, stays looking great all day.

★★☆☆☆

Mikki B**** · Ontario

Cat Eyed Smudges

I am not a huge liquid eyeliner fan to begin with, but I thought that I would give this product a try. It was definitely black which is something that I liked, but the ease of use just wasn't what I thought it was going to be. It smudged easily and was a little sloppy. It might be user error as I admit I don't usually use liquid eyeliner, but I gave it my best shot and still came out a mess. I'll probably return to a pencil.

★★★★★

Agnieszka C**** · Ontario

LOVE this liner

This liner works fantastic especially to make fine lines like cat eyes - as the liner boasts. I love this liner and will definitely continue using it in the future!

★★★★★

Shauna · Ontario

Outstanding!

I think I have found my new holy grail liner! I wing my liner daily, and currently purchase a specialty liner that is more than double the price of the L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir. I was hesitant to purchase this liner due to bad experiences with drug store liners in the past, and I thought the price was a bit much. I found the liner on sale today . . . and wow! The felt pen allows for a precise point, it glides without gaps across my lid, and dries to an opaque matte finish. I'll have to see how long the pen lasts to gauge the true value, but as of now I can't see myself going back to my old favourite. Thanks L'Oreal!

★★★☆☆

H J**** · Ontario

Pricey line

I found the liner very easy to use, was able to do thin lines as well as thicker, for someone who had never used a liner before it was great. Price tag was a little high for what it is in my opinion

★★★★☆

Sally R**** · Ontario

Easy To Apply, Easy To Remove

I like this L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir. It is very easy to apply. I just found the tip a bit dry. I thought the liquid liner would go right to the end of the brush but it didn't. It was just a little dry. Overall I really liked it except for the dry end. It just took a little extra effort to get it to the full extent of my eye lid because of the dry end of the pointed brush. It dried nicely and was very easy to remove with a make-up wipe.

★★★★★

Josee B**** · Quebec

super j ai bien aimé facile a appliqué

Bon rapport qualité prix il est facile d application fait de belles lignes et ne tache pas , il sèche assez vite ce qui est un gros avantage . Je le recommande fortement .

★★★★★

Tuyet P**** · Ontario

Sharp and sleek looking liner that give the contou

I have Asian eyes and this liner give me more definition and sleek and dramatic looking.

★★☆☆☆

Tasha C**** · Ontario

I really hate writing bad reviews :/

I really, really wanted to love this product. I love the cat eye look, but I am so not a fan of this eyeliner. I tried using it, and within 10 seconds it stopped working. I think because it got eyeshadow on the tip from trying to line my eyes (I always put liner over my eye shadow, and have never had this problem). Then I noticed that it is the EXACT same product as the Joe Fresh eyeliner I have, that I paid like 1/3 of the price for. (I wish I could upload some pictures to this review so you could see). I feel like a horrible person when I write bad reviews, but seriously I wouldn't recommend this product to anyone sorry :(

★★★★☆

Renee G**** · New Brunswick

Definitely purchasing again

I found the packaging a little bulky but once you see the eyeliner tip the packaging can be overlooked. Draws a precision line and goes on smooth. Would definitely purchase again.

★★☆☆☆

Amber M**** · Ontario

Not my first choice

Not a fan of this stuff. Will let my daughter have it . Like another liner wayy better . Hard to get it to come out right . Wouldn't buy again

★★★★★

Sherry G**** · Ontario

long lasting wear

This product was extremely easy to apply. It went on smoothly and without any mess. It lasted all day and was then easy to wash off.

★★☆☆☆

Cheryl H**** · Ontario

Goes on easy, smudges too easy

I enjoy wearing eyeliner so when I had the opportunity to try this product I was pretty excited. however after using this product I was very disappointed with the results I found that it took way too long to dry, it smudged very easily and even though it applied easily it didn't seem to stay on very well.

★★★★★

Elizabeth D**** · Ontario

Smoothest ever eye liner.

This eyeliner was the easy to apply, and quite easy to remove as well once the day is done. I found it doesn't smear or smudge. It feels nice and smooth when applying it to my face. My daughter used it too and felt it is the best one, from a couple others she had tried. It is easy to make cute little designs around the eyes with too. I think that anyone who likes to give their eyes a little extra, this is perfect.

★★★☆☆

Alicia R**** · British Columbia

Not bad, just not for me!

I had the opportunity to try L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir. I have never used a liquid liner before so it was a bit difficult for me, I'm used to a pencil. The color was not as dark as I would have liked. I probably would just stick with the pencil, it is much easier application and much cheaper to purchase. If you like liquid, I'm sure you would like this product though.

★★☆☆☆

Tammy W**** · Nova Scotia

Very disappointed

The liner has a very nice fine tip, but it is somewhat stiff. I found it a bit difficult to get a nice smooth line. The color is a nice deep rich black, but once applied the liner smudged terribly. It did not dry quickly, therefore smeared when opening my eye. It was somewhat difficult to remove the liner with eye makeup remover as it just smeared more, instead of wiping off nicely. I would not recommend this product .

★★★★☆

Annie M**** · Ontario

Dramatic effects

If you don't want drama in your life, but rather in your eyes, then liquid liner is the way to go. Good product but hopefully a softer black will be available.

★★★★★

Faaiza R**** · Alberta

perfect for feline looks

i gave up liquid liners and opted for pencil liners long time ago, pencil liners don't give the fine cat eye look. this liner has a thin tip, the pen like shape gives better hold and precision and liner is dries smudge resistant.

★★★☆☆

Shelley K**** · Manitoba

Liked some features, but overall....not for me

I was looking forward to trying the L'Oreal voluminous liner noir. I usually use a pencil liner but I really liked the idea of a liquid marker liner. I liked the fine tip of the liner and it went on so smoothly and precisely. I think it would be nice for those that like to do a cat's eye. I just did a conservative line on my top lid. The dark black I found too harsh for me. Unfortunately, while the liner went on so nicely, it did not have good staying power. I found that it smudged and flaked off quite a bit throughout the day. I will probably stick with my pencils

★★★★★

Nadia J**** · Alberta

Perfect make up tool

Perfect eyeliner. Smooth finish. Clean lines. Definitely going to buy. Would recommend. Wish the price was not that high.

★★★☆☆

Monique S**** · Ontario

Good Product - does with it claims to

I found the shape of the product to be quite comfortable to use. I thought the brush was a bit too thin for me. I found it difficult to begin the application and needed to go over the eye a few times in order to get the necessary thickness. If I just did one line, it would be way too thin. Perhaps the thinness of the brush is required to achieve the cat eye look. I did not attempt this, so cannot speak to the ease of achieving this. I had trouble locating the product in store. When I purchased, the only available type was #300 - Blackest Black. It definitely is a dark black, a bit too dark for my personal liking. The colour lasted all day, and did not smudge or leave residue during the day. I used a makeup remover cloth to remove the liner. I don't think removal would have been very easy with my regular scrub cleanser. The Voluminous Noir Liner does what it claims to. However, I prefer to use another brand which is less expensive and easier to apply.

★★★★★

Kimberley L**** · Newfoundland and Labrador

loreal liner noir

I love his liner. It went on easily and effortlessly. Thief colour was perfect and made a very precise line. The look was perfect and I loved the way it applied. The would recommend this.

★★★☆☆

Sheryl B**** · Ontario

Fine lines for a steady hand

The L'Oreal Voluminous Liner allows very fine lines on your eyes IF you have a steady hand. Sadly I don't have a very steady hand and made quite a mess trying to apply this liner.

★★★★☆

Andre R**** · Quebec

Mince et léger, facile à manipuler

Format presque ergonomique de par sa forme et son poids. La pointe permets une meilleure définition au niveau du trait. Prends quelques essais pour s'habituer à son utilisation, mais une fois habitué il est plus agréable.

★★★★★

Avery W**** · Ontario

Excellent product that makes a perfect winged eye

This is the first time I've used this product and it was fantastic. It gave a perfect winged look because the applicator is thin and easily to use. It was quite popular as well since I was able to get the last one on the shelf!

★★★★☆

Sn K**** · Ontario

Good eyeliner

It's a nice eyeliner pointed tip helps for fine line, was very easy to apply lasted for long time . Really liked it very much.

★★★★★

Leona T**** · Ontario

Great liquid eyeliner!

This eyeliner really helps, it's easy to glide on smoothly and long-lasting! The pen works amazing and the tip is very precise with no difficulties to apply . I can do thick and thin lines without a problem and also define. It helps me to create my smoky look and stay all day long. Easy to remove, too! Love this liquid eyeliner, and highly recommend!

★★★★☆

Nidi K**** · Ontario

good liner

its a nice liner , like other liner too , i use other brand i compared both and felt this is almost like my other brand but this last for long time dosnt get pealed off.

★★★★★

Kim C**** · Ontario

Wing liner

This liner works great and is easy to apply once you get the knack of how to put it on. Will probably not buy this product again as it is too expensive for my taste.

★★★★☆

Lynda V**** · Ontario

Easy to use as long as you can draw straight lines

This product works well. I found the price a little high but it does work well. I tend to shake while trying to line the eye and because I wear glasses and need to remove them to put eyeliner on it can a little challenging

★★★★☆

Dimpi K**** · Ontario

Very nice product

I liked this eyeliner easy to use cosistancy is very nice , very easy to apply dosnt get spreaf out over eye after some time like other liner do. It kept this for a long to see how it goes , skin under it was not dry didn't feel itchy after I removed it . Overall a very good product my only concern was a the price.

★★★★☆

Shaiwah F**** · British Columbia

nice product

This glides on smoothly with a thin, stiff point. The color lasts all day, and is a deep black color. but be careful sometimes can smudge. beginners need to b more careful

★★★☆☆

Nikita B**** · Newfoundland and Labrador

Smooth application

This glides on smoothly with a thin, stiff point and the color lasts all day. The only down fall is that after a few days of application the felt tip dries out a little and the lines aren't as bold.

★★★☆☆

Natalie K**** · British Columbia

L'Oréal volume liner noir

This product glided on nicely But it didn't last at all throughout the day Great color and thickness of aplicater, just don't have any lasting affects for all day I don't think I would purchase this product again, as it smudged allot

★☆☆☆☆

Katrina B**** · Quebec

Difficult to use

I love felt tip liners. I was excited to try this new one from L'Oreal. I found the shape of the barrel novel but awkward to use.. even more, the cap only goes on a certain way which is annoying. The main problem I had was the tip. It is very firm which some people might like but I am used to tips with slightly softer ends. I find that it makes it easier to apply across the lashline because it is flexible and it curves with the eye. The L'Oreal Voluminous liner was rigid and stiff and difficult to apply along the lashline. It will probably be good for drawing the cat eye in the corner of the eye but generally it was a struggle to use.

★★★★☆

Kimberley C**** · Ontario

Long Lasting Cat-eye

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir is an ultra-fine tipped liquid liner perfect for creating a cat-eye look. I found the liner easy to use and liked the fine tip. The tip helped with creating smooth lines and the end of the cat-eye at the outside of the eye. This liner boasts that it is smudge resistant and lasts all day which I did indeed find to be the case. It stayed put all day at work and throughout the evening. Overall a great liquid liner.

★★★★★

Kelly C**** · Ontario

Love this product.

This new L'Oreal liquid liner is by far my new favorite. It goes on smoothly and is awesome for how evenly it goes on. You can make nice clean lines and the black is nice and dark. Great liquid liner.

★★★★☆

Lily L**** · British Columbia

Great liquid eye liner

Very convenient to use and long lasting

★★★★☆

Lila L**** · Quebec

Easy to use providing a clean line. Looks great!

I haven't used liquid liner until now. I wasn't sure how well it would work and if I would like how it looks. I've used it a few times and with each use perfected my technique to create the look I wanted. I am quite pleased with the product.

★★★★☆

Saskia V**** · Ontario

Fuller lashes

Fuller beautiful lashes

★★★★☆

Lysianne S**** · Quebec

Ultra precise liner

I love that this liner had a super fine tip. It allowed me to contour my eyes with precision and without too thick of a line. It was easy to use, but I didn't like the cap and the way it had to fit a certain way (got my fingers dirty when I took it off, and it took me a little while to close it properly). The liner held on all day despite some minor tears due to the cold (no smudging). Great product and i would definitely recommend it and use it again!

★★★☆☆

Collette T**** · Manitoba

Helping the cat eye

This definitely helps make the cat eye easier although it did take some getting use to the tip of the pen. After a few clean-ups I finally got the hang of it. The eyeliner applies smoothly and give a nice clean look which I absolutely love. Stands up well to every day use too. No more smeared eyes for me!

★★★☆☆

Mary-Lynn S**** · Ontario

Good Product but not for Me

I have discovered, that while this product was easy to use and happy to try it out; I look ridiculous with the cat look. However the liner is very effective and does create a bold look very easy. And the jury is still out on whether or not i will continue to use it. Please don't let my review affect your judgment since that look may be much better for you.

★☆☆☆☆

Erica M**** · Ontario

Not a good liquid liner

I found this product to be awful! What a waste of money. I will start out by stating that the design of the product was nice. The pen fit nicely in my hand and was not uncomfortable to hold. I did like that design aspect of it. However as for the felt tip and the eyeliner I was not pleased at all. The tip was stiff and hard and barley came onto my eye lip unless I pushed really hard. It was almost like it was already dried out.

★★★★★

Frances M**** · Alberta

Smooth lines

L'Oreal Voluminous Liner Noir goes on very easily. I'm am by no means an expert on eyeliner, but this liner goes on smoothly with just one swipe. The applicator creates a nice line of varying thickness depending on pressure. I also have oily skin and it is still there hours later.

★★★★☆

Michelle C**** · Ontario

Gorgeous and Dramatic

It's a voluminous liquid black eyeliner with an ultra fine tip. I love the color noir, very dramatic. I normally use black. Stays on very well and easy application with the ultra fine application. I love how the liner itself is easy to use for your fingertips. Lasts all day and looks fabulous. I would love to see more colors.

★★★★☆

Melody S**** · Alberta

Grea Liner

This product was great. Usually dont use liquid, but a pleasure to try. Liner was easy to put on and brush kept its form. Lasted the whole day!

★☆☆☆☆

Shannon T**** · Ontario

Terrible liner

I did not like this liner. It did not go on as smooth as other liners.

★★★☆☆

Katie N**** · Ontario

Good but not amazing.

I was so excited to try this liner! The packaging was very attractive, the liner itself was really cute. I will say that I used an eyelid primer prior to applying this liner, as I usually do. So, I tried it. I found it was really smooth and very easy to use. Getting a thin line was extremely effortless. I was really impressed. Definitely would be great for traveling and on the go, if you need a quick touch up. I found about 4-5 hours after applying it, I had a black line on the top of my eyelid, so the liner was transferring off of my eyelid up higher, which is NOT good- and that was with wearing an eyelid primer... If it wasn't for that, I would have given this a 5 * but I can't do that. My current liquid eyeliner won't smudge or transfer ever, even after 12+ hours of wear, still looks the same. I love the ease of use and the convenience of this liner, but the transfer of the black line is not acceptable for me. I wanted to love this completely!

★★★★★

Aleena M**** · Alberta

Amazing look

Amazing look very easy to use. Easy the glides. Gives a very clean look. Define tape makes blind very smooth. Definitely going to recommend. Definitely going to buy

★★★★☆

Brianna C**** · Ontario

Thickens lashes

Great eyeliner making my lashes thicker and fuller

★★★★★

Diane V**** · Ontario

Luminous and Defined

I found this product gave really good definition to my eyes. It was easy to use and apply. With the thin brush, I was able to get an accurate brush stroke and make it thick or thin, depending on where I was going. A definite new purchase.

★★★★☆

Erin M**** · Ontario

Easy application

I am new to liquid eye liner and this one was very easy to use. I like the fact you don't need keep dipping it back in to get more product on the tip, and the smooth lines it makes. The only thing I find inconvenient is having to over the line to make it darker. I would definitely recommend this product to my friends and family.

★★★★★

Crystal J**** · Ontario

Great product

I like that it's liquid cause it goes on so much easier and I love black it makes my eyes stand out more. It was easy to use I love the design and the way the lid goes on really different.

★★★★★

Helen D**** · Ontario

Mesmerizing rich eyeliner

Very easy application with the ultra fine tip, smooth rich formula. Did not smudge lasted all day.

★★★☆☆

Kim C**** · Ontario

L'Oreal Voluminous Liner Noir

Although I trust the L'OREAL name, I wasn't smitten with this liner. The packaging is nice and the liner easy to hold. It's a bit pricey for what it is. I found the liner a bit tricky to apply and it seemed to dry quite quickly so if I messed up it was hard to touch it up. The black colour is beautiful and it lasted a long time with no smudging once I had it applied the way I liked.

★★★★☆

Tammy W**** · Ontario

this was very easy to use

I found this very easy to use. Was a very dramatic and intense colour. Great staying power!

★★★★☆

Sarah O**** · Ontario

Hello eyes

I really enjoyed using this product, it was so easy to apply! Didn't run at all an stayed in place all day without smudging. I got lots of compliments about how my eyes seemed to be popping.

★★★★★

Melanie · New Brunswick

Smooth and sexy

I love liquid liner so i was excited to try this liner. Loreal makes excellent products and this is another one. Love how smooth and clean the lines are. I definitely recommend this liner. Its so easy to use and i doesn't smudge. It stays clean and looks sexy. I will buy again and this is a keeper.

★★☆☆☆

Sandra J**** · Alberta

Disappointed

I applied the liner this morning and it was easily applied. I was very disappointed though when my eye teared and the liner ran everywhere. It went all over my eyelid and then ran into my eye. I am aware that the product did not state waterproof, but this was like watercolor paint. For the price point, I would expect a higher quality product.

★★★★☆

Erin S****

Great coverage Easy application

I love how easy it is to use. Great bold black coverage. A little expensive

★★★☆☆

Annette E**** · Manitoba

Just okay.

I wear eyeliner almost every day - I'm used to using liquid liner, although I have used liquid liner pens similar to this before. For me this one was just okay. I did 2 tests with it - one with no eyeshadow and one with full makeup, and had the same results with both. - It stayed very one on the eyelid itself - Although it was easy enough to draw "wings" with them, they didn't last a whole evening and smudged/wore off within a few hours. - The rest of the liner did get a little smudgy as well - It definitely needs a good makeup remover to take it off effectively.

★★☆☆☆

Debbie D**** · Ontario

Very nice product.

I found that I really like this product except for it is expensive compare to what I already use.

★★★★★

Penelope N**** · Quebec

Absolutely adore this liner!

I usually use pencil eyeliner so I was a bit concerned that the liquid black might look harsh. Well, I didn't need to worry - it gives a nice soft line, but one that stays on all day and continues to look as good as when first applied. It is easy to apply and glides on nicely, but also came off easily at bedtime with eye makeup remover. This will now be a staple in my makeup case.

★★★★★

Melanie H**** · British Columbia

Very easy to use

I really enjoyed this liner. The tip is precise and makes it super easy for me to wing my liner. I wore this out for the night and it stayed super well. The colour is also super black and pigmented which I love. I really love this liner!

★★★★★

Natsumi P**** · Saskatchewan

Great liner!

I have been looking for a better eye liner and this is it. I always worry about get smudge around my eyes but it doesn't.

A ShopperArmy product review. It is no longer open.

More to try

Try tomorrow's products. Get rewarded today.

Join 151,000+ members who test new products and earn cash, gift cards and free products.